Judicial Overview on equating False Promise to Marry and Offence of Rape

A sacred bond, founded on trust and mutual understanding, constitutes the essence of a holy marriage. Regrettably, in today's society, some individuals exploit this sacred institution for personal gains and undue advantages, causing immense emotional trauma and pain to their partners.

According to a recent court ruling, engaging in a physical relationship based on a promise of marriage that later proves unattainable due to relationship issues does not fall under the c of rape. Justice Pattanaik emphasized the importance of distinguishing between disputes arising from a ‘breach of promise’ and ‘false promises’ to marry. He clarified that a breach of promise, made in good faith but ultimately unfulfilled, should not be regarded as deceitful sex under the false pretence of marriage. Thus, if a promise was genuinely intended but circumstances led to its failure, the offense under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code is not established. However, a promise that is deceitful from the beginning can be considered rape.

This court ruling emerged during a recent judgment on a petition challenging the legality of criminal proceedings involving charges of cheating, sexual assault, and criminal force to outrage modesty. The case involved a relationship that deteriorated after seven years. Justice Pattanaik stressed the importance of distinguishing between relationships that began genuinely and those tainted by mistrust and dishonesty. The court argued that a sour relationship arising from an initially genuine friendship should not automatically categorize the male partner as a rapist. As per the case records, the woman involved had entered into a relationship with the petitioner while still legally married. Although the petitioner initially showed interest in marrying her, the promise was eventually broken due to the woman's personal reasons for not being ready for marriage at that time. The court also noted that both parties were educated and socially aware individuals who engaged in a relationship that gradually became one-sided. Consequently, the court deemed it unjust to accuse the petitioner of rape. However, whether the charge of cheating could still be established requires further investigation.

Rape is a grave criminal offense that involves non-consensual sexual intercourse or penetration. False promises to marry, while morally reprehensible, do not fall within the legal definition of rape in most jurisdictions, including India. In India, the offense of ‘cheating’ is covered under Section 415 of the Indian Penal Code, which encompasses situations where a person dishonestly induces another person to deliver any property or valuable security based on false promises or representations. If someone deceitfully obtains financial or material benefits from another person by promising marriage without any genuine intention to marry, it could potentially be a case of cheating.

Moreover, Indian courts have recognized ‘breach of promise to marry’ as a civil wrong. In such cases, if one party makes a false promise of marriage with no intention to fulfill it, and the other party suffers damages as a result, the aggrieved party may be entitled to seek compensation for the emotional distress and other losses caused by the broken promise.

It is crucial to consult a legal professional or refer to specific case law for a comprehensive understanding of the legal implications and available remedies in cases involving false promises to marry in India. Laws may vary, and court decisions evolve over time, so it is essential to have accurate and up-to-date information when dealing with legal matters.

Here are some notable cases related to false promises to marry in India:

1.    Varsha Kumari vs. Anil Kumar - In this case, the Supreme Court of India ruled that false promises to marry, made with the intention to deceive and without any intention to fulfill the promise, can amount to an offense of cheating under Section 415 of the Indian Penal Code. The court emphasized that the false promise of marriage must be made with the intent to deceive and induce the other person to part with property or suffer any other detriment.

2.    S.P.S. Balasubramanyam vs. Suruttayan - The Supreme Court held that a false promise to marry followed by sexual intercourse amounts to a breach of promise to marry and gives rise to a civil liability for damages. The court acknowledged the importance of considering such cases in the context of the social, cultural, and economic realities prevalent in Indian society.

3.    Kamlesh Kumari vs. State of Rajasthan - The Rajasthan High Court ruled that if a man induces a woman to engage in sexual relations by falsely promising to marry her and later refuses to fulfil the promise, it can be considered an offense under Section 376 (rape) of the Indian Penal Code. The court determined that obtaining consent for sexual intercourse by deception of marriage negates the voluntary nature of consent.

4.    Nithya Anand Raghavan vs. State - In this case, the Madras High Court held that false promises to marry cannot be equated with rape under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code. The court clarified that even if a person falsely promises to marry, it does not change the consensual nature of sexual relations.

It is important to note that these cases represent specific legal interpretations and should not be considered an exhaustive list. Laws and judicial precedents can evolve over time, so it is always advisable to consult with a legal professional for specific advice based on the current legal landscape.

VR Associates Law Firm - A leading criminal law firm in Gurgaon, has expertise in handling criminal law.

Adv. Vipin Raina and his team are known for putting their wholesome research and experience when it comes to Criminal Law, they have the most experienced set of criminal lawyers in India. Our team of best Criminal Lawyer In Gurgaon believes in fighting for the justice of our clients. 

Consult with an Expert criminal Lawyer in Delhi NCR, Please call us at +91–9667714993.